Cold brew coffee is no longer a niche only reserved for the most seasoned coffee enthusiasts. Word has quickly spread over the last few years of the smooth, full-bodied flavor profile that cold brewed coffee provides, and now it seems like there are more choices than ever when it comes to brewers.
Because of this, it can be a little difficult when trying to find the best cold brew coffee maker for your own use, thanks to the overwhelming amount of options. We went ahead and did the research for you, testing out a number of different brewers.
Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Beat Airtight Cold Brew Coffee Maker
The Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Below, you’ll see our top picks for the best cold brew coffee brewers, which includes the best brewers overall.
Winner: Willow & Everett Glass Pitcher Cold Brewer System
This particular cold brewer from Willow & Everett favors both style and function, combining a sleek, modern look with some very easy-to-use brewing features, and a highly affordable price. The result is the best cold brew coffee maker on the market.
The actual pitcher is made from high-quality glass that tapers slightly upwards from the base, with an angular handle extending from the back. A stainless steel lid maintains an airtight seal on the top, just above the filter assembly.
As for the filter itself, it extends down through most of the pitcher, holding enough grounds to brew over just 32 ounces at a time. The fiter is made from stainless steel, and has two separate layers, preventing even the smallest bit of grounds from getting into the coffee.
The pitcher is marked on the outside, so you always know exactly how much water you’ve added, or how much coffee you have left. A pour spout on top allows for mess-free and accurate pours.
The pitcher has a very modern look, but without being too edgy. The clear glass assembly and sharp design makes it versatile enough to compliment any decor type, while also being a good conversation piece. The stainless steel accents are the perfect match to its look.
Once the coffee has been brewed, the filter assembly can be easily removed, and replaced with the BPA-free silicone ring and stainless steel. This lets you store the cold brew for up to two weeks, keeping it fresh and free from any odors in your refrigerator.
Overall, this brewer is as simple as it gets, while still offering all of the features and design one could want with a cold brew coffee maker. It looks great, brews perfectly, keeps grounds out, and lets you store and serve from the same pitcher. Make this your first choice.
Runner Up: Willow & Everett Cold Brew Coffee Maker
This cold brewer from Willow & Everett is an excellent choice for those wanting to use their pitcher both inside and outdoors. Using a familiar design and brewing setup, this durable brewer is intended to be simple in operation, while having an added sense of versatility.
The pitcher is made from borosilicate glass, which is practically unbreakable. This makes it ideal for outdoor use when entertaining guests, as you won’t have to worry about having to clean up shards of glass if it gets knocked over by accident.
The brewer’s filter sits inside the middle of the pitcher, and is made from nylon. This is another example of its overall durability, and helps ensure that grounds are kept out of the coffee during the brewing process. The filter and pitcher can accommodate up to 1.3 quarts of cold brew at a time.
The actual brewing process is quick and easy. Simply fill the filter with the appropriate amount of grounds, fill the pitcher with water, and insert the filter into the pitcher, securing it by screwing the top in. The let the brewer sit for anywhere from 12-20 hours, and remove the filter.
Once the coffee has been brewed and the filter removed, the brewer can function as a serving pitcher, or to store the coffee in the refrigerator for a few days. The brewer’s understated looks allow it to blend in with any style of decor.
Although it’s not very flashy, this cold brew coffee maker does everything you need, and also provides you with a stylish way to store and serve your cold brew, all in a durable package that’s ideal for outdoor use as well. The low price point is just another reason why it ranks so high on this list.
Alternative: Coffee Panda Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Coffee Panda’s cold brew coffee maker is another great example of a durable and versatile cold brewer that offers many uses, and can be used in several different environments. Although it’s the most expensive brewer on this list, its high capacity and overall quality make it a solid choice.
The Coffee Panda brewer’s pitcher is made from durable borosilicate glass that is made to withstand the rigors of outdoor use. With a capacity of 1.3 liters, this brewer offers some extra space to brew more coffee at once, which is ideal if you have a larger family, or are having a few people over.
The fine mesh filter can be easily removed, and prevents any grounds from making their way into the coffee while brewing. Like other brewers, the process is the same, and takes around 12-24 hours, depending on your preferences.
Once the brewing is complete, you can unscrew the filter, and replace it with the pitcher’s top to lock in freshness and turn the brewer into a serving pitcher. In addition to using durable glass construction, the brewer also has a rubber no-slip bottom to ensure it stays in place on smooth surfaces.
Although this brewer wasn’t designed to be stylish, it still has a clean, appealing look that offers plenty of versatility, and won’t offset the rest of your kitchen or patio setup. Clear glass and black trim is always a good choice.
Coffee Panda throws in a few extras with the brewer as well, including a small recipe book that offers some ideas for using your cold brew, aside from the standard milk and sugar. And, just in case you need a little help getting started, there’s a manual included too.
If you’re looking for a cold brew coffee maker that can make bigger batches, and has the durability needed to be used inside and outdoors, this brewer from Coffee Panda deserves some strong consideration.
The Best Airtight Cold Brew Coffee Maker
And here are the best air tight brewers that are good for both brewing and storing the coffee afterwards:
Winner: Willow & Everett Sealing Cold Brew Coffee Maker
While most cold brewers now have some sort of lid that allows you to store the coffee in the refrigerator after brewing, not all of them have airtight sealing lids. The advantage of having an airtight lid is rather obvious, as it keeps the coffee fresher, and prevents other smells from getting in.
This sealing cold brew coffee maker from Willow & Everett offers an airtight seal, along with a superior filter and pitcher design that lets you brew more coffee at once, and all in a stylish package that is sure to draw a few looks from guests.
The pitcher is made from high-quality, shatterproof glass, and has mason jar-like design to it, giving it a unique appearance that mixes a vintage aesthetic with modern appeal. A rounded glass handle allows for easy pouring.
The brewer’s dual mesh filter is made from stainless steel, and offers an added layer that ensures that even the smallest coffee grounds are prevented from getting into the the final product. Once the brewing is complete, you can easily left the filter out before serving or storing.
After the filter is removed, you can reattach the BPA-free silicone ring onto the stainless steel lid, which can then keep an airtight seal, letting you store the coffee for up to two weeks at a time. Markings on the outside of the pitcher show you how many ounces are inside.
In terms of finding a stylish cold brew coffee maker that is equally suited for brewing, serving, and storing, while offering added room to accommodate bigger batches, you won’t find anything better. Those who need airtight storage with their brewer should make this their top choice.
Runner Up: Twohundred Cold Brew Coffee Maker Pitcher
This sleek cold brew coffee maker from twohundred offers a sleek and modern look, along with a basic design and near airtight seal. Boasting more of a minimalist appearance, this brewer is good for anyone that prefers simple styling, and also needs a way to store their cold brew for longer periods.
The pitcher's glass is made from the popular borosilicate variety, giving it added durabiity, without the need to use harmful plastic material. There is no handle built onto the pitcher, which you may or may not appreciate, depending on your preferences.
Using the pitcher is easy, and follows the same familiar steps you’ll find with similar modes. Place your coarse grounds into the filter, add the water, and allow the brewer to sit overnight for anywhere from 12-24 hours, or whatever you prefer.
The filter itself is fine mesh and made from stainless steel, and also completely dishwasher safe. You can use it with most anything, including fruit and tea leaves. Removing the filter can be done in a matter of seconds.
Once you’re ready to store the coffee, simply remove the silicone ring and place it onto the pitcher’s lid, which will then make a near airtight seal, slowing oxidation and protecting the flavor of the coffee.
Twohundred also throws in an e-book that contains several different recipes you can try out with your cold brew if you’re feeling adventurous, or willing to try something new.
While this cold brew coffee maker from twohundred isn’t the best among the airtight options, it’s still a great product that ranks in the upper tier of cold brewers, and has a very appealing price point as well.
Why Should You Choose Your Cold Brew Coffee Maker Carefully
Not all cold brew coffee makers are made the same, even if they all do create the same final product.
Brewers come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and range from being the simplest brewers with a basic setup and design, to more complicated products that have a number of convenient features.
Choosing the right brewer for yourself means being aware of what your needs are beforehand. Otherwise you run the risk of ending up with a cold brewer that is less than ideal, which wastes your money and time.
What To Pay Attention When Choosing Your Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Here are a few common aspects to be aware of before making a buying decision with your brewer.
The actual capacity of the brewer is definitely one of the most importantcharacteristics. One of cold brew coffee’s advantages is that it can actually keep for a long period after brewing, unlike hot coffee or conventional iced coffee.
Because of this, it’s often good to brew your cold brew in large enough batches to where you can have enough for an extra day or two after that first glass.
Larger capacity brewers allow you to brew less due to the bigger batch size. And since cold brew coffee is not something you can just make in a few minutes, the ability to make larger batches is a nice one to have, even if it’s just a few more ounces.
Not concerned with brewing an extra amount? Then any size will do.
While not usually a deal-breaker, a filter type is still something you need to be mindful of. The majority of cold brewers are going to either have nylon or stainless steel mesh filters, but there is some variance.
Stainless steel is often more preferred, as it has greater longevity and doesn’t interfere with the coffee’s natural oils as much.
The filter may or may not be removable from the brewer’s pitcher as well. The easiest filters are ones you can quickly take out of the pitcher or carafe.
Ease Of Cleaning
Cold brew coffee makers don’t use electricity, and they aren’t all that complicated, so most of them are going to be pretty easy to clean for the most part.
Still, there are some brewers that are even easier to clean than normal, whether that means they can quickly break down for better cleaning access, or are made from materials that let you run them through a dishwashing cycle.
If you value having a brewer that’s exceptionally easy to clean and deal with in general, pay close attention to its design.
Additional features are always nice to have with cold brewers. Again, these are simple brewing devices, but some products are a little more innovative than others, giving you a better product in many ways.
Some of the more helpful extra features include thing slike outside measurement markings so you can keep track of the exact water level when brewing. Ergonomic handles, airtight lids, no-slip bottoms, and fully removable filter baskets are generally appreciated as well.
While looks don’t have an impact on how the coffee is brewed, the aesthetic of the brewer is important to most. This is especially true when considering that many people use their brewers as serving pitchers as well.
We all have different tastes when it comes to looks, but there are definitely some cold brewers that make an effort to have an appearance that stands out, and making it an asset for your kitchen counter or coffee table.
There are also plenty of brewers that are aiming for a more minimalist look, allowing them to blend in better with contemporary decor. Either way, it’s all up to you.
Although the amount of choices can be overwhelming, it’s a good thing that coffee lovers have so many choices when shopping for cold coffee brewers. Hopefully this guide has narrowed things down for you, making your shopping easier.
While all of the above brewers are good products, we certainly have our favorites, and strongly recommend them for your cold brewing needs. Just be sure to go over your requirements before buying, ensuring that you get the perfect brewer you can rely on for years to come.